On friendship, the shadow, and the grace that meets us there
By Maida Mascorro
Criticism can invite us to look inward. A few days ago, a dear friend and I were chatting, as we do whenever life allows. She mentioned that someone had reacted negatively to a birthday gift I had sent her, and it stung.
I brushed it off with, “Oh well, that just shows how insensitive and closed-minded some people can be.” But the more I sat with it, the more I sensed I shouldn’t dismiss it. People will be people, with their own opinions, sense of humor, and beliefs, and I cannot know what lay behind their words.
Sitting With the Sting
In the quiet days that followed, I grieved somewhat, both for her and for me. In my own friendships, I’ve noticed that the moments that initially feel uncomfortable or even painful often carry the richest lessons.
When a friend’s words or actions unexpectedly stir something within me, it’s rarely about them alone. It’s an invitation to recognize and embrace parts of myself I may have neglected or feared. These reflections have taught me patience, humility, and the importance of leaning into vulnerability rather than retreating from it. Over time, I’ve seen how allowing these tender moments to surface can deepen trust, foster mutual understanding, and create a space where both friends can grow in compassion and spiritual awareness together.
A Practice for the Moment: NON-JAR-D
Then, I remembered what I teach my clients: the NON-JAR-D technique, an acronym I created that draws on Eckhart Tolle’s teachings on inner peace. It is a simple way to meet criticism (or any other issue) without being ruled by it.
-
- Don’t judge
-
- Don’t assume
-
- Don’t react
-
- Detach
The Shadow, and a Note on Perspective
Before we hung up, I had briefly touched on the Shadow self, the part of ourselves we have hidden, denied, or never learned to accept, and I felt nudged to share these reflections with you.
A note on perspective: The “shadow” is a Jungian psychological concept, not a clinical diagnosis or proof of a supernatural bond. Christian symbolism offers a separate spiritual lens. This reflection uses both, and each can enrich the other without replacing it.
In what follows, I look at how close friends can mirror one another’s hidden parts, how they can help each other heal, and how bringing those parts into the light with Christ can turn a stinging remark into grace.
1. How Best Friends Can Recognize and Trigger Each Other’s Shadows
A close friendship can become a sacred mirror. A friend may express qualities we have buried, feared, admired, or never felt free to claim.
In Jungian terms, projection can occur when we meet in another person something we struggle to recognize in ourselves. Admiration, protectiveness, irritation, fear, or tenderness can become invitations to self-examination, and to grace.
Not every intense reaction is projection; sometimes we simply see another person clearly. A helpful question to carry into prayer is: “Why does this quality in my friend touch me so deeply?”
2. How Two Friends May Protect and Help Heal One Another
Best friends need not carry identical wounds. One may have learned, “I always have to be strong,” while the other learned, “I need someone safe enough to let me be vulnerable.”
In a loving friendship, one may slowly discover, “I do not always have to be the strong one,” while the other discovers, “I can be vulnerable without being abandoned.”
Scripture honors this kind of friendship: “Faithful are the wounds of a friend.” (Proverbs 27:6, KJV) A friend’s honest word, received with humility, can become a means of grace.
Even so, neither friend is meant to become the other’s permanent healer or rescuer. Rather, the safety of the friendship helps each woman recognize a wounded or hidden part of herself and take prayerful responsibility for its healing and integration.
3. Bringing the Hidden Self into the Light of Christ
Sections 1 and 2 looked at how friends mirror and help heal one another. The Christian lens adds a further question: what do we do with the hidden parts of ourselves that a friendship, or even a criticism, brings to the surface? The Jungian shadow should not automatically be equated with sin, evil, or spiritual darkness. More often it holds what is tender rather than wrong.
Often what we push away is not sinful at all. It may be the frightened child, grief, vulnerability, the longing to be loved and affirmed, righteous anger, or the God-given ability to set boundaries. Consider why that remark about my gift stung so much. Perhaps the sting was not about the critic at all, but about a tender part of me that still wants to be accepted.
Instead of judging the critic or defending ourselves, we can pause, breathe, and ask:
| “Lord, what is this reaction showing me?” |
This is offered for prayerful discernment, not as a declaration of what God definitively means. Recognize the hurt child as part of yourself, then bring that child into the light with Christ, who receives every tender part of us with compassion rather than condemnation.
Questions for Discernment
Take these questions slowly. There are no right answers, and one question may be enough for today. Ask God to show you only what you are ready to see, and let each answer come as an invitation rather than a verdict.
What our friendship reveals
-
- What quality in my best friend immediately touches my younger self?
-
- What part of me feels safest, most at peace, when she is present?
-
- What vulnerable part of her seems to emerge specifically with me?
-
- Do I protect in her something I once wished someone had protected in me?
-
- What does she embody that my younger self was never allowed to become?
Pain, criticism, and growth
-
- When our friendship stirs up pain or fear, what might that reaction be revealing about each of us?
-
- When an unexpected criticism touches me, what tender part of myself might it be revealing, and how can I bring that part to Christ instead of brushing it aside?
-
- Does our friendship help each of us become more honest, responsible, compassionate, and spiritually grounded?
A Closing Reflection
Best friends often wonder whether their shadow selves are somehow connected. Perhaps the deepest question is not “Are our shadow selves connected?” but rather: “What does this friendship, and even a stinging remark about a simple gift, reveal in each of us that is asking to be seen, understood, healed, and brought into the light?”
Have you ever experienced anything like this in your own friendships?
A friendship can be spiritually meaningful without two souls being supernaturally linked. Its holiness lies in how each person helps the other encounter truth, vulnerability, growth, and grace.
A Closing Prayer
Heavenly Father, thank You for friendship and for the people who mirror Your love back to us. Give us gentle eyes to see what has been hidden and courage to bring every wounded part into Your light. Teach us not to judge, assume, or react, but to rest in Your peace. Where we have been hurt, bring healing; where we have been closed, bring grace. Give us grace to receive criticism with an open heart, and to bless and release those whose words have stung us. May our friendships help us grow in truth, compassion, and faith. Amen.
“Search me, O God, and know my heart: try me, and know my thoughts.” (Psalm 139:23, KJV)
Your Invitation This Week
This week, I invite you to choose one of the Questions for Discernment and sit with it in prayer or in your journal. Write down the first thing that surfaces, without judging it, and then offer it to God.
Suggested Sources for Further Reading
-
- C. G. Jung, Aion: Researches into the Phenomenology of the Self.
-
- C. G. Jung, The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious.
-
- For Christian reflection, read Psalm 139 and other passages on truth, light, confession, grace, renewal, and discernment alongside Jung’s ideas about the hidden aspects of the self, noting where the two perspectives meet and where they differ.
